A Defense of Democratic Principles
Former Kaduna State Governor, Mallam Nasir El-Rufai, has issued a strong warning against the unconstitutional removal of elected officials, particularly in light of the recent declaration of a state of emergency in Rivers State. Speaking at a press conference on Thursday, El-Rufai cited a 2006 Supreme Court judgment to emphasize that the suspension or removal of governors and legislators during an emergency is illegal. His remarks come as a timely reminder of the importance of upholding constitutional provisions in addressing political crises.
The Legal Precedent: A 2006 Supreme Court Ruling
El-Rufai referenced a landmark 2006 Supreme Court judgment that clarified the limits of Section 305 of the Nigerian Constitution, which governs the declaration of a state of emergency. The court ruled that the provision does not permit the removal or suspension of elected officials, including governors and legislators, during an emergency. “It is true that in those cases, the governors were suspended. These suspensions were challenged in court, and in 2006, the Supreme Court of Nigeria gave a judgment clearly stating that under no circumstances can the emergency provision in Section 305 be used to remove any elected official. That is the law,” El-Rufai stated.
The former governor stressed that this ruling remains binding unless a constitutional amendment or new legislation explicitly changes it. His comments serve as a legal counterpoint to the recent actions taken by the federal government in Rivers State, where Governor Siminalayi Fubara and his deputy were suspended for six months following the declaration of a state of emergency.
The Only Lawful Path: Impeachment by the Legislature
El-Rufai reiterated that the only constitutionally recognized method for removing a sitting governor is through impeachment by the state legislature. He emphasized that any other approach, including the use of emergency powers, is unlawful and undermines democratic principles. “Unless a constitutional amendment or legislation explicitly changes this ruling, no authority, whether federal or state, has the power to remove a sitting governor outside due legal process,” he said.
His remarks highlight the importance of adhering to constitutional processes, even in times of crisis. By invoking the 2006 Supreme Court judgment, El-Rufai is calling for restraint and respect for the rule of law in handling political disputes.
The Rivers State Crisis: A Test for Democracy
El-Rufai’s statement comes amid ongoing debates about the implications of the state of emergency declared in Rivers State by President Bola Ahmed Tinubu on Tuesday. The suspension of Governor Fubara and his deputy has sparked widespread criticism, with many arguing that the move sets a dangerous precedent for executive overreach.
The Rivers State crisis has exposed deep political tensions and raised concerns about the stability of democratic institutions in Nigeria. El-Rufai’s intervention serves as a reminder that constitutional provisions must be upheld, even in the face of political instability.
Read also: “Life Made Easier Under Tinubu: Interior Minister Highlights Security and Service Improvements”
A Broader Context: Protecting Democratic Norms
El-Rufai’s warning is not just about Rivers State but also about safeguarding Nigeria’s democratic system as a whole. His emphasis on the 2006 Supreme Court judgment underscores the need to protect the integrity of elected offices and ensure that political disputes are resolved through lawful means.
The former governor’s remarks also reflect a broader concern about the erosion of democratic norms in Nigeria. By speaking out, he is joining a growing chorus of voices calling for accountability and respect for the rule of law.
Upholding the Constitution in Times of Crisis
Nasir El-Rufai’s press conference is a timely reminder of the importance of adhering to constitutional principles, even in times of crisis. His reference to the 2006 Supreme Court judgment provides a clear legal framework for addressing the ongoing situation in Rivers State and serves as a warning against the unconstitutional removal of elected officials.
As Nigeria navigates this challenging period, El-Rufai’s message is clear: democracy must be protected, and the rule of law must prevail. The Rivers State crisis is not just a test for the federal government but also a defining moment for Nigeria’s democratic future.